|
Racists Are Mad About the TERF Show, and They Want Me To Do Something About It? | |
Posted May 6, 2025 - 10:25:51
|
|
So this situation just honestly amuses me so much that I had to share. It also requires a lot of background, so please bear with me as I try my best to explain.
I actually got this email a couple of weeks ago, but I needed to share it with y'all because... well, because. Unless this is your first time reading anything I've ever written, you probably know that I'm one of the people behind Nerd & Tie, which is primarily a podcast network these days. We also still dabble in convention news coverage, but between 2014 and 2018 we ran the "Mega Blog" on the site where we covered pop culture news. Was that a long time ago? Yes. Was that only for a brief period in the site's twelve year history? Also yes.
But because of that our tips email has ended up in the hands of people who want to send out releases and blast every nerd news site they can find. Which is, y'know, absolutely fine. It's a dedicated mailbox, and that's literally what it's for.
And most of the stuff that gets sent there is pretty typical and what you expect... and then, there are emails like this one.
Before we start, I want to mention something important: Nerd & Tie is a primarily queer run network. There are not an insignificant number of trans creators involved, and I personally am nonbinary. Anyone who has spent more than five minutes with our content would know this, and knows our current distaste for anyone supporting a certain wizarding franchise and its creator. Said wizarding franchise has a new TV adaption coming out soon, and they've done something which will always send the worst people you've met into a tizzy: they cast a non-white actor in a role that was white in the original version.
So yeah, the racists are losing their god damned minds -- and they emailed us about it.
To be fair, this was clearly a form email they sent to a ton of folks, but since it wasn't BCC'd, it means they thought of us specifically, and that makes it all the funnier. They're really trying to sound formal and professional with this wacky-ass thing, so, with the subject line "Media coverage request: HBO Max controversy, #NotMySnape movement and the silencing of fan voices," this is the email I got:Dear editorial team,
I'm reaching out to draw your attention to a situation currently causing major unrest within the global Harry Potter fan community - a story I believe deserves media coverage.
HBO Max previously announced a new Harry Potter TV series, claiming it would stay true to the original books by J.K. Rowling. However, over the past months, rumors surfaced about a casting direction focused on inclusivity, raising concerns about deviations from the canon.
A few days ago, HBO officially announced Paapa Essiedu, a Black actor, as Severus Snape - a character explicitly described in the books as "sallow-skinned" and "deathly pale." The announcement was posted with comments disabled, preventing fans from voicing their reactions. As a result, the community rallied on other official pages (such as @hbo itself, @StreamOnMax and @HarryPotter on Instagram), giving rise to the #NotMySnape movement.
Unfortunately, HBO appears determined to silence dissenting voices by reporting comments as spam and ignoring legitimate criticism. Millions of fans feel unheard and censored, all in the name of a "woke" culture that should, in theory, embrace diversity - including diversity of thought and opinion.
I kindly ask if you could consider writing an article on this matter, highlighting the injustice and double standards in HBO's handling of the situation.
Thank you for your time and commitment to independent journalism.
Best regards,
V. This is, frankly, the funniest god damned thing I've ever read. From the word woke in scare quotes to the "diversity of thought and opinion" we are getting the dog whistles in full on symphonies. I like how they describe HBO deleting overt racism as an injustice.
Like imagine living in 2025 and this is your biggest problem.
The best part is, a lot of people on the left don't want this show to exist at all, and think it's weird they made the in-canon wizard-racist character black. Like that's sort of problematic for a myriad of reason, but none of them are what these bozos are angry about.
And honestly I personally would LOVE IT if this show failed, so if the racists don't tune in... and the leftists don't tune in... that's awesome. Good job Warner Bros, you really did it with this one.
The email also attached a bunch of screenshots of HBO social media, I guess to prove the censorship? I don't honestly didn't give a shit and ignored them.
To top it off, I got a second email about it a week later from another sender titled "Recast Snape! Not my Snape movement," and it's just as funny as it tries to argue about the casting with book quotes:Dear people who care about our voices,
HBO has casted Snape as a version that doesn't match the books entirely:
-"Snape's sallow skin had gone the color of sour MILK." From Prisoner of Azkaban, Chapter 14, page 285
- "Snape was hanging upside down in the air I...] revealing skinny, PALLID legs." From Order of the Phoenix, Chapter 28, page 647
- "Voldemort, looking into Snape's PALE face..." From Deathly Hallows, Chapter 32 page 655
We are not racists who put our eyes on the actor's race. What we deeply care about and is concerned is the film presenting the accuracy of the books. When HBO announced the remake, they promised that the main purpose to remake the series was to stick to the books as much as possible. However, the results are highly disappointing.
Also, HBO deleted ALL our comments on one of their posts about the remake (
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DI0fcvdPi8o/?igsh=MWkxdHdycTdkejI4eg==
), silencing over hundreds of voices from us. Not to mention they closed off comments of the post where they announced Snape's cast. They are silencing over hundreds of our voices and refuse to listen nor communicate with us.
Please, if you care about the voices and the freedom of speech of our people, report this and let more people know.
Thank you! I'm just... I'm just laughing. "We're not racist, but... it's just super important to us that the character is white!" Like I could argue with this on the basis of adaptation, or that it's not important to the background of the character -- but who gives a shit? Imagine spending this much energy on fucking TV adaptation casting of the TERF-owned wizard franchise. Imagine sending this to me of all people an expecting a sympathetic ear. If you don't like an adaptation choice, don't watch it. Feel free to criticize it too -- but to send things like this to me of all people... wow.
I wonder what living a life that privileged is like.
It just made me laugh.
- Traegorn
I hope you'll forgive my commentary on this subject, but honestly, I really don't like changing major aspects of a character in a story, simply to change the mix. If the actor in question can Viking mythological god was a good idea, but hey, I was glad to be wrong. There are very few other actors of any race, creed, or what have you, who could have pulled that role off as well as he did. And now, the rumor is, they are going to replace the late Alan Rickman with a black actor? I will be quite disappointed if the actor they choose isn't at least of Idris Elba's caliber, as Alan Rickman is going to be a very hard actor to follow.
And, yes, I am a heterosexual white male, and I don't really give a $#!t about race nor anything else like that, but I do have a problem with changing a character, just to be politically correct. If they can do the job, fine, but if not, I'll be sorely disappointed.
Unless the story requires such a change, I feel changing things just to change them does a disservice to the Author, the Audience, and the Actors themselves. People watch movies and TV shows for entertainment, not to be preached at or told how wrong they are, stapled to established characters and stories to prove some sociopolitical point, you remove the viewer from the immersion of the story, thus providing them with an experience that is less than it should be avoided, if possible.
What I'd say if this were a normal show in response: I think it's weird to cast a black actor as the canon racist-Wizard, but in truth there's nothing character defining about them being white. No actor is going to match the late Alan Rickman.
What I actually think: Fuck JK Rowling and anyone who watches this show to begin with. No one should give her a single dime ever again, and her IP should die in cultural irrelevancy. Any actor working on the show should quit anyways.
|
![Trae Dorn [dot] Com](http://www.trhonline.com/traedornproductionslogo-2025-web.png)
